“Enough is Enough, He’s let us down, NOT at the level to play in the PL”- ALL fans agrees must with the club to Axe to signing in January after series of awful performances
Timo Werner’s return to Tottenham Hotspur has been a profound disappointment since he re-joined the club last summer. His lackluster performances have left fans and management questioning the initial decision, and as January approaches, Spurs face a pressing choice: to cut their losses by terminating his loan deal or to persist with a player whose contribution thus far has been well below par.
The German forward was brought in to provide attacking depth and dynamism, but he has not delivered any of the qualities expected from a top-tier forward. Werner’s game has been devoid of creativity, flair, and, most crucially, a goal threat—an essential attribute for any player aiming to make a difference in the final third. For Tottenham fans, this lack of impact is sadly familiar, as his underwhelming numbers from his initial six-month stint in north London did little to inspire confidence.
Werner’s struggles aren’t isolated to his time at Tottenham. After failing to establish himself as a reliable scorer or playmaker at Chelsea, where he was unable to adapt to the intensity and defensive rigors of the Premier League, he returned to RB Leipzig in hopes of revitalizing his career. However, his stint back in Germany was short-lived. Despite being welcomed back to Leipzig with open arms, his time there was marked by inconsistency, and he quickly found himself out of favor, consigned to the bench even though he remained a popular figure among fans of the Red Bull Arena.
Tottenham’s decision to bring Werner back into the Premier League was born out of necessity rather than strategy. Faced with an injury crisis that left their forward line depleted, Spurs were desperate for reinforcements and saw Werner as a temporary solution. His arrival, however, was seen by many as a puzzling move, particularly given Leipzig’s eagerness to part ways with him—a warning sign that perhaps should have been heeded by Tottenham’s recruitment team. Nevertheless, the club decided to roll the dice, hoping Werner could fill the gap, at least temporarily.
Despite a modest return of two goals, three assists, and three significant goal-scoring opportunities created during his first stint, Spurs chose to extend Werner’s stay for another year. This decision raised eyebrows, as his performance metrics fell well short of what Tottenham needed to make a serious push for the top-four. Werner’s acquisition became Tottenham’s first summer signing, a move that many critics and fans saw as lacking ambition and direction.
As the season unfolded, it became clear that Werner’s influence on the pitch was as limited as ever. Currently, he has managed only one assist across six Premier League appearances, and despite being given two starting opportunities, his impact has been negligible. His statistics tell one side of the story, but the aesthetic and style of his game reveal even more about his struggle to find a rhythm. Werner has appeared to lack confidence, and his tentative approach often leaves him isolated from the flow of play, with little connection to the other attackers.
For a club like Tottenham, aspiring to compete at the highest level, having Werner as the main backup for Son Heung-min is a troubling signal. Son, a dynamic and proven goal-scorer, sets the standard, and to have Werner as his understudy speaks volumes about the squad’s current limitations and Spurs’ wavering ambition.
After witnessing his uninspired performances, Tottenham should have re-evaluated their decision after Werner’s first stint. Instead, the club has found itself in an all-too-familiar position, where Werner’s second opportunity has fallen even flatter than his initial spell. His lack of confidence, coupled with fundamental weaknesses in his attacking game, continues to hold the club back from achieving their potential.
In January, Tottenham faces a critical decision. If they are genuinely committed to re-establishing themselves among the Premier League’s elite, cutting ties with Werner would be a bold, necessary move. His departure could open the door to a more impactful addition, a player who could bring the skill and confidence Tottenham need in the final third. By moving on from Werner, Tottenham would not only rectify an error in judgment but also send a message about their commitment to building a squad capable of competing at the highest level.