The New York Mets have emerged as one of the most active and ambitious teams during this offseason, positioning themselves as serious contenders for the upcoming MLB season. Their most significant move has undoubtedly been the acquisition of superstar Juan Soto, a marquee signing that instantly elevates their roster. However, the Mets haven’t stopped there—they’ve also made several additional free-agent signings to strengthen their squad further. Despite these efforts, the team still finds itself one piece short of completing what could be a championship-caliber lineup.
Currently, the Mets are exploring their options to fill the final spot in their batting order. The flexibility of Mark Vientos, who can competently play either first base or third base, opens up possibilities for the front office to target players at either corner infield position. One obvious solution would be to re-sign their star first baseman, Pete Alonso, ensuring continuity while adding Soto to an already potent lineup. This approach would enable the Mets to retain the core of their 2024 roster and make a strong run in 2025 with minimal adjustments.
However, the team appears to be contemplating an alternative strategy that could significantly reshape their infield. According to recent reports, the Mets are actively considering signing a free-agent third baseman rather than bringing back Alonso. Renowned MLB insider Jon Heyman from The New York Post suggested that the Mets remain firmly in the mix for Alex Bregman, one of the most sought-after names in free agency. “I’m not going to rule out [Alex] Bregman to the Mets at this point,” Heyman commented, fueling speculation about the team’s plans.
Bregman’s market has been robust, with several high-profile teams—including the Detroit Tigers, Boston Red Sox, and New York Yankees—expressing strong interest in his services. His value is reflected in the lucrative contracts being projected for him, with most analysts estimating he could secure a deal worth around $200 million. By comparison, Alonso’s potential contract is expected to be in the $150 million range, making Bregman the pricier, yet arguably more impactful, option.
The Mets’ deep-pocketed owner, Steve Cohen, has shown a willingness to spend big when necessary, so financial constraints are unlikely to hinder their pursuit of either player. The decision ultimately comes down to priorities: Bregman appears to be the team’s preferred choice, given his ability to provide elite production at third base, while Alonso serves as a solid fallback option should the Mets fail to land Bregman.
From a strategic standpoint, it’s understandable why the Mets have yet to re-sign Alonso. Their current focus on Bregman suggests they are aiming to maximize their roster’s versatility and offensive upside. If Bregman signs elsewhere, the Mets can pivot back to Alonso, ensuring that their lineup remains formidable heading into the new season.
This offseason, the Mets have demonstrated a clear commitment to assembling a team capable of competing at the highest level. Whether they ultimately opt for Bregman or Alonso, their aggressive approach signals their intent to build a roster that can challenge for a World Series title. As the free-agent market heats up, the next few weeks promise to be pivotal in shaping the Mets’ 2025 campaign.
BREAKING: Mets agrees to Cut Ties With Fan Favorite Pete Alonso and sign $200 Million star in a blockbuster deal
