The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves treading familiar waters yet again. In 2024, optimism briefly shone through a 10-3 record, fueled by solid performances from Russell Wilson and Justin Fields at quarterback. However, as has become an unfortunate tradition, the team faltered down the stretch. A once-promising season ended with Pittsburgh stumbling into the playoffs, only to be soundly defeated by an opponent with a more dynamic offense. It’s a recurring storyline that has left Steelers fans frustrated and weary.
The disappointment has reignited calls for change, with some questioning the future of head coach Mike Tomlin. As the enduring face of the franchise and a paragon of stability, Tomlin’s position has long been seen as unshakable. Yet, some argue that a fresh start might benefit both the Steelers and their veteran coach. For Pittsburgh, it could represent an opportunity to rebuild; for Tomlin, it might mean a chance to revitalize his career with a team of his choosing. Despite this growing sentiment, a parting of ways remains unlikely. Tomlin’s three-year contract extension signed before 2024 and his consistent ability to defy low national expectations make his departure improbable.
Jim Rooney, brother of Steelers owner Art Rooney II, offered a broader perspective on the team’s struggles. Speaking on the Ross Tucker Podcast, Rooney emphasized that the blame cannot be placed solely on Tomlin. “I think it’s an organization issue, not just Mike,” Rooney explained. “I think all of us are responsible for the outcomes, but I think we take responsibility. I don’t want to get into excuse-making, but the reality is we outperform the NFL mean at a greater rate than just about any team for the last 25 years.” He added that when considering the challenges Pittsburgh has faced, the team has consistently exceeded expectations under Tomlin’s leadership.
Rooney pointed to the adversity the Steelers face in a highly competitive AFC North, home to elite quarterbacks like Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson. Despite this, Pittsburgh has remained a steady presence in the playoff conversation, even with subpar quarterback play for much of the past decade. Each year, when analysts predict the Steelers will finish at the bottom of the division, Tomlin somehow keeps them in the Wild Card race.
However, as Rooney acknowledged, the ultimate goal is winning Super Bowls, something Pittsburgh has failed to achieve in recent years. “Having said that, I understand no one wants to lose playoff games,” Rooney noted. “The goal is to win the Super Bowl, and you have to get there. You have to get to playoff games, which we do well, and you have to win playoff games, which we haven’t.” This admission highlights a significant concern: has the franchise settled for mediocrity, prioritizing consistency over true contention?
For some fans, the Steelers’ apparent contentment with merely staying competitive falls short of their championship aspirations. Yet the risks of moving on from a coach like Tomlin, who has yet to work with a truly elite quarterback in nearly a decade, are considerable. Hiring a new head coach always comes with the potential for failure, and for Pittsburgh, that risk may outweigh the reward.
Tomlin has certainly faced criticism for the team’s shortcomings, and his leadership is not without flaws. But he has consistently kept a flawed roster competitive, even in the face of significant challenges. If Pittsburgh were to dismiss him, it would need to be after providing him with a franchise quarterback capable of taking the team to new heights. Until then, Tomlin has earned the opportunity to remain at the helm, even as the franchise grapples with how to rise above the plateau it currently occupies.
The Steelers’ faithful may be restless, but Tomlin’s track record of defying expectations and keeping the team afloat in turbulent waters cannot be ignored. The road to a Super Bowl may seem distant, but it’s one Tomlin deserves the chance to navigate—provided the team can give him the tools he needs to succeed.