Newcastle fans slam ‘joke’ decision as Premier League club announces retained list
Newcastle United Release End-of-Season Retained List, Sparking Mixed Reactions Among Supporters
Newcastle United have officially unveiled their end-of-season retained list for the 2024/25 campaign — and the decisions have stirred up strong, conflicting opinions among fans.
The Magpies concluded a memorable and largely successful season, securing a Carabao Cup triumph and clinching qualification for next season’s UEFA Champions League. These achievements mark a major step forward for Eddie Howe’s side as they continue to evolve into one of English football’s most exciting and ambitious projects.
Among the standout performers this term were Italian midfielder Sandro Tonali and Swedish striker Alexander Isak, both of whom played pivotal roles in the club’s success. Tonali bounced back impressively following his early-season suspension, while Isak’s clinical finishing and all-around attacking prowess made him the focal point of Newcastle’s frontline. Both players are expected to remain central to the club’s plans moving forward.
However, attention has now turned to the club’s contract decisions and the future of several senior players. On Friday afternoon (June 6), Newcastle released their official retained list via the club’s website, confirming a number of key developments.
According to the statement:
“Callum Wilson and John Ruddy are set to be out of contract at the end of June. However, the club has opened discussions with both players about their futures, and new contracts could still be agreed.”
Meanwhile, it was confirmed that Jamal Lewis, who has struggled for regular game time during his stint on Tyneside, will depart St. James’ Park once his contract expires this summer.
In addition, the club confirmed that Lloyd Kelly, who joined on loan from Juventus earlier in the season, will make his move permanent for an undisclosed fee on June 30.
As for the rest of the squad, Newcastle are opting for continuity.
“All other first-team players are retained,” the statement continued, “with an option activated to retain goalkeeper Mark Gillespie, following recent contract extensions for Fabian Schär, Emil Krafth, and Dan Burn.”
Divided Fanbase Over Callum Wilson’s Potential Stay
While much of the announcement was expected, it’s the situation surrounding Callum Wilson that has divided opinion among the fanbase. The 33-year-old striker has faced a series of injury setbacks in recent seasons and endured a particularly frustrating 2024/25 campaign — failing to score in any of his 18 Premier League appearances.
Many fans have taken to social media to express their surprise and concern at the prospect of Wilson being offered a new contract. Some argue that, with the club now competing in Europe, every squad spot is vital and should be occupied by players who can contribute consistently on the pitch.
One frustrated supporter wrote:
“Wilson is a ridiculous choice. It also casts doubt on a homegrown GK coming in and Sean Longstaff leaving. All a bit odd.”
Another added:
“Just let Wilson go — he literally said his goodbyes to the fans already.”
A third fan echoed similar sentiments:
“Utter joke that. Every squad space is vital for a European season. We need a fit, active striker to rotate Isak.”
Wilson Opens Up About His Difficult Season
In a candid interview on the High Performance podcast last month, Wilson opened up about the emotional toll of transitioning from being the club’s first-choice striker to taking on a more peripheral role.
“You go from being first-choice striker to then being second-choice striker,” Wilson admitted. “Every game, there is not even a contest on who starts at the moment, and rightly so. In my absence over the last 18 months, Alex has just gone to another level, which is fantastic for the team.”
Despite the disappointment, Wilson says he has tried to adapt his mindset and contribute in whatever way he can — even off the pitch.
“My role changes and you have to put your pride and ego to the side. If I can’t be a big part on the pitch, how can I help off it? How can I support other players and remain a positive influence?”
He also acknowledged that being out of contract has added to the emotional weight of the season:
“It’s difficult, but I think I’m getting the balance right. I’ve gone through dips and all sorts of emotions — this summer has brought challenges I’ve never had to face before.”
What’s Next?
With Newcastle preparing for a busy summer transfer window and the added demands of Champions League football next season, the decisions made in the coming weeks will be crucial. Whether Wilson and Ruddy sign new deals remains to be seen, but the club appears focused on maintaining a balance between experienced leadership and youthful energy.
As always, fan sentiment reflects the high expectations surrounding the club — and time will tell whether these choices prove wise as Newcastle embarks on another pivotal season.