‘A player that I admire’: James Garner is set to reunite with his former teammate as he is playing a major role in bringing him to Everton

Garner Faces Uncertain Future as Moyes Prioritizes Midfield Reinforcements — Could Fred Be the Final Nail?

 

James Garner may be facing a crucial summer at Everton, with growing indications that his role under incoming manager David Moyes could be under review. The former West Ham boss is reportedly not fully convinced by the 23-year-old just yet, and with central midfield named as a top priority in this transfer window, Garner’s place in the squad may be hanging in the balance.

 

Sources suggest Everton are actively pursuing reinforcements in the middle of the park, which naturally puts pressure on players like Garner, who are still trying to cement themselves as automatic starters. While Garner has shown glimpses of his quality since arriving from Manchester United, consistency has been an issue — and it’s something fans and, potentially, Moyes have taken note of.

 

Although Garner has delivered at key moments, especially during challenging periods last season, his overall impact has remained a topic of debate among supporters. The uncertainty is now compounded by the club’s interest in a high-profile midfield addition — former Manchester United and current Fenerbahçe player Fred.

 

Interestingly, Fred, now 32, has previously expressed deep admiration for Garner. Their paths crossed at United, where both trained and played during overlapping spells. In a 2020 interview with Brazilian outlet Trivela, Fred singled Garner out as the most impressive young talent at the club, praising his vision, passing ability, and calmness on the ball.

 

> “Not because he plays in the same position, but James Garner really stood out,” Fred said.

“His game vision, passing, and technique were all impressive. I truly admire him.”

 

 

 

Now, with Everton reportedly considering a £15 million move for Fred, there’s a fascinating narrative brewing — one of admiration turning into competition. While Fred’s respect for Garner is clear, his arrival would undoubtedly increase the pressure on the Englishman to perform.

 

Garner could play an important role in persuading Fred to join the Toffees, especially given their previous relationship. However, his contribution off the pitch might not be enough to protect his status on it.

 

Compounding matters, Moyes is believed to have concerns about Garner’s set-piece delivery — a key responsibility that could soon be handed to Dwight McNeil, who has proven more consistent in dead-ball situations. If Moyes feels that Garner’s role can be better filled by someone with more composure or precision in these moments, it might prompt a change in the pecking order.

 

Fred, known for his tenacity, work rate, and energy in midfield, could offer exactly the kind of box-to-box dynamism Moyes is craving. That versatility might be just what the manager needs as he looks to reshape the spine of Everton’s team. With both players operating in similar roles, a direct comparison is inevitable — and Garner may find himself edged out if he doesn’t step up.

 

Everton fans are already split on the idea of Fred’s return to the Premier League. While some remember his inconsistent displays at United, others see him as a seasoned midfielder who brings experience, tactical awareness, and leadership — qualities that could prove vital in a transitional period under Moyes.

 

There’s no doubt that Garner has potential — even Brentford boss Thomas Frank has spoken highly of him in the past — but in a Moyes-led side where performance trumps promise, he must now prove that he can be more than just a highly regarded prospect.

 

With preseason around the corner and the transfer window heating up, the next few weeks could define Garner’s future at Goodison Park. While Moyes has acknowledged Garner’s quality in private discussions, his broader message to the squad is loud and clear: no one’s place is guaranteed.

 

If Fred does arrive, it could create an intriguing dilemma. Will the two forge a formidable partnership — or will the mentor-turned-rival push Garner further down the pecking order?