Fabrizio Romano Reveals Major Twist in James Trafford Transfer Saga as Newcastle United and Man City Circle

 

The long-standing transfer pursuit of Burnley goalkeeper James Trafford has taken a dramatic turn, with Manchester City now considering a shock move to re-sign their former player—putting Newcastle United’s hopes of landing the talented shot-stopper in serious jeopardy.

 

At just 22 years old, Trafford has already built an impressive reputation. He played a pivotal role in Burnley’s remarkable 2022/23 Championship campaign, keeping a staggering 29 clean sheets and conceding only 16 goals, setting a new defensive benchmark as the Clarets stormed back to the Premier League at the first attempt.

 

Trafford had originally been on the verge of joining Newcastle last summer, with Eddie Howe identifying him as a long-term successor between the sticks. However, negotiations collapsed when Nottingham Forest complicated a deal involving midfielder Elliot Anderson, reportedly demanding that Newcastle also include Odysseas Vlachodimos in a broader Profit and Sustainability Regulations (PSR) swap arrangement. The chaos ultimately shelved Trafford’s transfer at the time.

 

Fast-forward to the current summer window, and Newcastle revived their interest. Talks with Burnley resumed in earnest, with both clubs said to be close to agreeing a fee earlier this month. But progress suddenly stalled—leading to speculation that Burnley had moved the goalposts in their demands.

 

Now, world-renowned transfer insider Fabrizio Romano has added fresh intrigue to the situation.

 

💣 Romano’s Bombshell: Manchester City Enter the Frame

 

According to Romano, Manchester City—who sold Trafford to Burnley two years ago for around £19 million—are seriously contemplating activating a buy-back clause that was inserted into the original deal. This clause, reportedly worth over £40 million, would allow Pep Guardiola’s side to bring Trafford back to the Etihad if either of their current senior goalkeepers, Ederson or Stefan Ortega, depart this summer.

 

Romano revealed:

 

> “EXCL: Manchester City are considering a move for James Trafford to return to the club this summer… but only if one of their two main GKs leaves. Contacts took place in recent days as Man City have a buy-back clause, this is why the Newcastle deal is not sealed yet.”

 

 

 

City’s goalkeeper situation is far from settled. Ederson has been heavily linked with Galatasaray, while Ortega—though under contract until 2026—has hinted at wanting more regular football. Should either exit, Trafford would be a natural and familiar replacement.

 

🤝 Personal Terms Agreed with Newcastle

 

Despite the latest uncertainty, it’s understood that Trafford has already agreed personal terms with Newcastle United, underlining his willingness to make the switch to Tyneside. The stumbling block remains the transfer fee, with Newcastle reportedly negotiating around £35 million, which still falls short of City’s buy-back threshold.

 

This delay has opened the door for Manchester City to act swiftly, especially with the looming threat of losing one of their experienced keepers.

 

🗣 Trafford Speaks Out on Missed Opportunity

 

In a recent appearance on the Fozcast podcast, Trafford candidly discussed last summer’s failed move to Newcastle, expressing his frustration while maintaining his respect for Burnley and the Championship.

 

> “In the summer, I think people knew I wanted to move,” he said. “The club I was close to joining was a really good fit for me. I truly believed in it—it felt right for my career.”

 

 

 

> “It wasn’t about looking down on the Championship—I had no shame playing there. It’s a great league, and I don’t see myself as above it. But when you feel a situation is right, and the opportunity aligns with your goals, you have to try and take it. Unfortunately, it just didn’t happen.”

 

 

 

These honest reflections show Trafford’s maturity and professional mindset. Rather than dwell on the disappointment, he has continued to perform at a high level, earning admiration for his humility and drive to improve.

 

 

—

 

⚖ What Next?

 

The race for James Trafford is now a three-way tug of war involving Newcastle, Burnley, and possibly Manchester City. With personal terms already sorted and Trafford’s enthusiasm for the move clear, Newcastle remain hopeful. However, the presence of a looming £40m+ buy-back clause gives Manchester City a powerful advantage, should they choose to activate it.

 

As the summer window progresses and goalkeeper movements begin to unfold, Trafford’s future remains delicately poised. For Newcastle, it’s now a matter of urgency—and deep pockets—if they wish to get the deal over the line before the champions swoop in.