Every Premier League Goalkeeper Ranked Based on 2025/26 Data

The 2025/26 Premier League campaign has once again showcased the vital role of goalkeepers. From seasoned veterans fighting to maintain form to rising stars proving their worth, this season’s goalkeeping statistics tell a fascinating story. Using goals prevented versus expected data, here’s a look at the top 20 stoppers — starting with those having a tough season and finishing with the very best in England’s top flight.

 

20. Sam Johnstone – Wolverhampton Wanderers (-2.10)

 

It’s been a torrid campaign for Sam Johnstone and Wolverhampton Wanderers. The Englishman has conceded 2.10 more goals than expected, a figure that highlights the club’s defensive woes under Vítor Pereira. With Wolves rooted to the bottom of the table and having shipped a league-high 25 goals, Johnstone’s experience will be crucial if they are to mount any kind of resurgence. Despite his struggles, the former Crystal Palace man’s leadership and communication remain assets — qualities Wolves will desperately need to escape the relegation zone.

 

19. Alphonse Areola – West Ham United (-1.70)

 

A World Cup winner with France and once part of Paris Saint-Germain’s star-studded squad, Alphonse Areola has endured a difficult season at West Ham United. The 32-year-old has let in 1.70 more goals than expected, underlining a dip in form. While his reflexes remain sharp, inconsistency and lapses in concentration have hurt the Hammers. Considering West Ham’s ambitions for a European push, they may soon reassess their goalkeeping options.

 

18. Djordje Petrovic – Bournemouth (-1.60)

 

After struggling for minutes at Chelsea, Djordje Petrovic made the switch to Bournemouth to become their new No.1. The tall Serbian has shown flashes of brilliance but still has work to do — his stats reveal 1.60 more goals conceded than expected. At just 24, though, there’s plenty of room for improvement, and his shot-stopping ability hints at a bright future on the south coast.

 

17. Bernd Leno – Fulham (-1.20)

 

Bernd Leno, a graduate of Stuttgart’s academy and former Arsenal No.1, has established himself as a reliable figure for Fulham. However, the German has not been at his sharpest this term, conceding 1.20 more goals than predicted. His performances, while steady, haven’t quite reached the high standards he set in previous seasons — something the Cottagers will need him to rediscover soon if they are to avoid being dragged into mid-table obscurity.

 

16. Robert Sánchez – Chelsea (-0.90)

 

For a club that’s spent over £1 billion on transfers, it’s astonishing that Chelsea still rely on Robert Sánchez between the posts. The Spanish goalkeeper has been decent but unspectacular, underperforming by 0.90 goals. With competition in almost every other position, his starting role under Enzo Maresca speaks volumes about Chelsea’s unbalanced recruitment — and perhaps a lack of urgency to find a true world-class shot-stopper.

 

15. Altay Bayindir – Manchester United (-0.80)

 

Once tipped as one of the best backup goalkeepers in the world, Altay Bayindir hasn’t made the most of his chances at Manchester United. Before Senne Lammens claimed the No.1 jersey, the Turkish international struggled to impress, conceding more than expected and failing to inspire confidence. His limited opportunities since have made it difficult to recover momentum.

 

14. Matz Sels – Nottingham Forest (-0.80)

 

After arriving from Strasbourg in early 2024, Matz Sels quickly became a fan favorite at Nottingham Forest. His heroics last season helped the club secure European football, but this time around, his numbers have dipped. The Belgian has allowed 0.80 more goals than expected, though his shot-stopping and experience still make him a steady presence in goal.

 

13. Martin Dúbravka – Burnley (-0.60)

 

Veteran goalkeeper Martin Dúbravka, now plying his trade at Burnley, has bounced around several English clubs — including Newcastle and Manchester United. Under Scott Parker, he’s brought valuable experience to Turf Moor, performing just below statistical expectations. At 36, his composure and leadership remain vital as Burnley fight for survival.

 

12. Alisson Becker – Liverpool (-0.50)

 

A name synonymous with world-class goalkeeping, Alisson Becker continues to command respect. Since joining Liverpool in 2018, he’s helped the club lift virtually every major trophy. However, this season has seen a small dip, with the Brazilian conceding 0.50 more goals than expected. Even so, he remains one of the most dependable stoppers in world football.

 

11. David Raya – Arsenal (-0.40)

 

David Raya has been a calming presence behind Arsenal’s rock-solid defensive duo of William Saliba and Gabriel Magalhães. Though the Spaniard has kept seven clean sheets in 11 games, the numbers suggest he could still improve — with 0.40 goals more conceded than expected. Still, his composure with the ball at his feet perfectly suits Mikel Arteta’s tactical setup.

 

10. Bart Verbruggen – Brighton & Hove Albion (-0.20)

 

At just 23 years old, Bart Verbruggen has emerged as one of the Premier League’s most promising young goalkeepers. Having been linked with top clubs like Manchester United and Chelsea, the Dutchman has repaid Brighton’s faith with commanding displays. While his figures show a minor underperformance, his maturity and distribution mark him as one for the future.

 

9. Emiliano Martínez – Aston Villa (-0.10)

 

World Cup winner Emiliano Martínez nearly joined Manchester United last summer, but the move fell through. Remaining at Aston Villa, the Argentine has been solid, though not as outstanding as in previous campaigns. His performances have been steady enough, conceding just 0.10 goals more than expected — a testament to his reliability.

 

8. Lucas Perri – Leeds United (-0.10)

 

Brazilian goalkeeper Lucas Perri has quickly adapted to life in the Premier League under Daniel Farke. Sharing minutes with Dan Darlow early on, Perri has now established himself as Leeds’ first choice. Statistically, he’s outperformed his teammate and looks destined to become a long-term fixture for the Whites.

 

7. Gianluigi Donnarumma – Manchester City (+0.70)

 

Replacing Ederson was never going to be easy, but Gianluigi Donnarumma has stepped into the role with confidence. The 26-year-old Italian has brought composure and presence to Manchester City’s back line, preventing 0.70 more goals than expected. Pep Guardiola’s faith in him has been rewarded, marking a smooth transition in the City goal.

 

6. Senne Lammens – Manchester United (+1.50)

 

Senne Lammens has been a revelation since arriving from Royal Antwerp for £18.1 million. After replacing Onana and Bayindir, the Belgian has stabilized United’s defense, saving 1.50 more goals than expected. At 23, his rapid rise has made him one of the breakout stars of the season.

 

5. Nick Pope – Newcastle United (+1.50)

 

Back to his best, Nick Pope has responded superbly to the summer arrival of Aaron Ramsdale. His sharp reflexes and positioning have helped Newcastle maintain defensive solidity, with the England international saving 1.50 more goals than expected. His form could put pressure on Jordan Pickford ahead of the next international window.

 

4. Jordan Pickford – Everton (+1.70)

 

Everton’s talisman between the sticks, Jordan Pickford, continues to silence critics. The 31-year-old remains Gareth Southgate’s undisputed No.1 for England and has been in exceptional form, saving 1.70 more goals than expected. His leadership and consistency make him one of the Premier League’s most valuable assets.

 

3. Robin Roefs – Sunderland (+2.10)

 

New signing Robin Roefs has been nothing short of sensational for Sunderland. The 23-year-old Dutchman, brought in by Regis Le Bris alongside experienced names like Granit Xhaka, has prevented 2.10 goals more than expected, helping the newly promoted side stay competitive. He’s quickly established himself as one of the best young keepers in England.

 

2. Dean Henderson – Crystal Palace (+3.80)

 

After years of waiting for his big break, Dean Henderson has finally found his stage at Crystal Palace. The former Manchester United man has been pivotal in Oliver Glasner’s setup, saving 3.80 more goals than expected. His heroics were key in Palace’s FA Cup triumph last season, and his consistency has continued ever since.

 

1. Guglielmo Vicario – Tottenham Hotspur (+4.40)

 

Sitting proudly at the top is Guglielmo Vicario of Tottenham Hotspur. Since joining from Udinese in 2023, the Italian has been a revelation in North London, replacing Hugo Lloris with ease. Vicario has saved a remarkable 4.40 more goals than expected, underlining his status as the best-performing goalkeeper in the Premier League. Calm, agile, and commanding, the 28-year-old has become a fan favorite and a cornerstone of Tottenham’s new era under Thomas Frank.

 

Final Thoughts

 

From struggling veterans to record-breaking saviors, the 2025/26 Premier League season has offered a fascinating glimpse into the world of elite goalkeeping. While Vicario’s brilliance stands above the rest, emerging stars like Lammens and Roefs suggest that the future between the posts is in safe hands.