“He’s the major weakness in the squad, could cost them the Europa league too”- Jamie Carragher tells Ange to replace his top signing who has now become a “huge weakness” for Tottenham

Tottenham Hotspur suffered yet another disappointing setback in the Premier League, falling to a 2-1 defeat at home against relegation-threatened Nottingham Forest. The result adds to what has been a thoroughly underwhelming campaign for Spurs, and questions are mounting over the performance of key players—especially goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario, who came under intense scrutiny for his role in the defeat.
The loss further compounds Tottenham’s problems this season, leaving them languishing in 16th place in the Premier League standings. Unless they manage to win the UEFA Europa League, their hopes of securing European football for next season are rapidly slipping away. A club of Tottenham’s stature missing out on Europe would be a major blow, both financially and in terms of attracting top talent in the transfer market.
Throughout the season, Tottenham players have faced heavy criticism for their lackluster performances, and Vicario has now become the latest to face the heat. Despite showing glimpses of promise since arriving in North London, the Italian shot-stopper’s struggles with aerial balls and set-pieces have become a recurring issue. His inability to command his area and deal effectively with crosses has not gone unnoticed.
Former Liverpool defender and current pundit Jamie Carragher did not hold back in his analysis, highlighting Vicario’s vulnerability in dealing with balls into the box. Carragher noted that Premier League teams have begun to exploit this glaring flaw in his game, which is proving to be a serious liability for Spurs.
“They actually feel this is a huge weakness for Tottenham,” Carragher said, via the Daily Mail. “The goalkeeper’s not great. He’s not great on the first one, he’s not great on this one either. He’s never great with the ball coming into the box. It’s definitely something they’ve identified that this is a weakness for Tottenham Hotspur.”
As the pressure mounts, Tottenham’s coaching staff will be under scrutiny to address the issue, whether through tactical adjustments or a change in personnel. Opposing teams are clearly targeting Vicario’s weakness, and unless he can quickly adapt and improve his command of the penalty area, the club may be forced to explore alternatives.
Looking ahead, the summer transfer window is shaping up to be a crucial period for Spurs. Reinforcements will be necessary across several positions, and the goalkeeping department could be among those prioritized for improvement. While Vicario has shown potential, consistency and reliability are non-negotiable qualities for a top-tier Premier League goalkeeper—especially for a club aiming to return to the upper echelons of the table and compete for silverware.
Tottenham still boast several talented players, but if they are to challenge for trophies in the near future, significant changes and improvements must be made. Addressing individual weaknesses—starting with the goalkeeper—will be key to rebuilding confidence and restoring the club’s competitive edge.