Troy Deeney noticed what ‘monstrous’ Brenden Aaronson did during Leeds United win
Few could have predicted it. As Leeds United prepared to face West Ham on Friday night, many fans were calling for Brenden Aaronson to be dropped from the starting XI. The American midfielder had struggled for form in recent weeks, and there was a growing sense that Daniel Farke might need to shake things up. Yet, against all expectations, Aaronson not only kept his place but went on to deliver what was arguably his best performance in a Leeds shirt.
Heading into the game, Aaronson admitted he had been wrestling with self-doubt. His confidence had taken a hit amid criticism from supporters and pundits alike. But Farke showed faith, naming the USA international in his starting lineup for the sixth consecutive Premier League match — a decision that paid off almost immediately. Within just three minutes, Aaronson found the back of the net.
It wasn’t a spectacular goal — more a poacher’s finish than a screamer — but it meant everything. His celebration told the story of a player who had rediscovered his belief. It was raw emotion and relief rolled into one, a visible release of the frustration that had been building for weeks. From that point forward, Aaronson seemed transformed — confident, dynamic, and fearless.
His best moment came when he picked up the ball near the halfway line, slalomed past three or four West Ham defenders with quick feet and balance reminiscent of his nickname, the “Medford Messi,” and unleashed a curling shot that grazed the crossbar. It was a reminder of the immense potential Leeds fans had glimpsed when he first arrived from RB Salzburg — a player capable of producing moments of real magic.
Recognition from Troy Deeney and Leeds fans
The performance didn’t go unnoticed. Leeds fans voted Aaronson as their man of the match, with a commanding 62% of the post-game vote. Among those impressed was former Premier League striker Troy Deeney, who selected Aaronson in his BBC Sport Team of the Week, calling his display “monstrous.”
Deeney also took time to applaud Daniel Farke’s bravery in sticking with Aaronson despite calls for change, particularly with both Jack Harrison and Dan James available for selection. “I think that was a huge call to put him in,” Deeney wrote. “There’s been a bit of a call for him to be dropped. He got the opening goal, missed a few chances in weeks before, but it was a monstrous performance. He stepped up into the game and took the initiative to be like, ‘I’m going to be the difference maker today.’ He showed why he should be in that Leeds team.”
Deeney’s praise echoed the sentiments of many Leeds supporters who have long believed that Aaronson’s energy and pressing make him invaluable, even when his final product falters. But on Friday, he showed that he can offer much more than relentless running — he can change a game with quality on the ball too.
Aaronson fighting for more than just a Leeds place
For Aaronson, this resurgence could not come at a more crucial time. Beyond his club ambitions, the 24-year-old is also battling for his international future. With the USA preparing for a home World Cup next summer, every performance is under the microscope. While teammates like Dan James and Willy Gnonto face uncertain national team futures — Wales and Italy’s qualification prospects remain unclear — Aaronson’s situation is different.
US head coach Mauricio Pochettino (hypothetically, in this context) will be closely monitoring his progress in England. Aaronson’s energetic displays in the Premier League could go a long way in securing his spot in the USA’s final squad for the 2026 tournament. The stakes are high — he isn’t just playing for Leeds’ survival, but also for the chance to represent his country on the biggest stage, in front of a home crowd.
Confidence returns for the ‘Medford Messi’
Friday’s showing against West Ham was a turning point — proof that Aaronson can be more than a workhorse. When he plays with freedom and belief, he brings flair, creativity, and tempo to Leeds’ attack. Farke’s decision to trust him looks inspired, and if Aaronson continues on this trajectory, he could become one of Leeds’ most influential players during the remainder of the season.
After enduring criticism and doubt, Aaronson has finally reminded everyone — including himself — that he belongs at this level. His blend of determination and skill could be exactly what Leeds need in their push for Premier League stability and what the USA will need as they build toward their home World Cup dream.