Manchester City striker Erling Haaland did not hold back in his criticism of referee Jarred Gillett after the official ruled out his dramatic late goal during City’s hard-fought 1-0 victory over Tottenham Hotspur on Wednesday night. The decision left the Norwegian star frustrated as he felt the call cost him a crucial moment in the match.
Haaland, who has been in sensational form this season, continued his goal-scoring exploits by netting his 28th goal of the campaign in the first half. However, the game’s most controversial moment came deep into stoppage time, as Haaland thought he had doubled his tally—only for the goal to be chalked off in what he and many City fans believed was an injustice.
The late-game drama unfolded in the eighth minute of added time, as City sought to kill off the match with a second goal. Amid a frantic sequence inside the penalty area, Haaland found himself in the right place at the right time, finishing past Spurs goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario. However, Gillett quickly blew his whistle, ruling that Haaland had handled the ball in the build-up after a scramble involving Tottenham’s Archie Gray and Kevin Danso.
While Manchester City’s players erupted in frustration, hoping VAR would intervene to correct the decision, the review process ultimately upheld the on-field call. VAR official Graham Scott carefully examined the footage but did not find a “clear and obvious error” in Gillett’s judgment, meaning the decision stood and Haaland’s goal was wiped off the board.
The ruling proved pivotal, as City held on for a narrow 1-0 win rather than sealing a more comfortable victory.
Haaland Fumes Over ‘Big Mistake’ and Questions Decision
Haaland, known for his goal-scoring prowess rather than outspoken criticism of officials, did not hide his frustration when speaking after the game. During his post-match interview on BBC Match of the Day, the 24-year-old striker was visibly disappointed and made it clear he believed the referee had made a major error.
“He made the decision on the pitch that it was a free-kick,” Haaland said.
“I don’t think it is. I think it’s clearly a big mistake, but we’re humans—we make mistakes. I think it was a goal, and I don’t think it was a handball at all. For me, it’s more of a handball from the defender, but what can we do?”
The Norwegian striker’s reaction resonated with many football fans, particularly Manchester City supporters, who felt that the ruling was harsh and inconsistent with similar incidents in recent matches. The frustration was amplified by the stakes of the game, as City continue their battle for the Premier League title and cannot afford to drop points in such a tight race.
Haaland’s remarks have also raised questions about whether his comments could lead to disciplinary action from the Football Association (FA). The governing body has, in the past, punished players for publicly criticizing referees, even in cases where their statements were measured and not directly inflammatory.
Former Referee Keith Hackett Defends Haaland’s Comments
Despite speculation over possible FA action, former Premier League referee Keith Hackett, who previously served as PGMOL general manager, believes that Haaland’s comments do not warrant any form of punishment. Hackett acknowledged the striker’s frustration but emphasized that he expressed his opinion in a reasonable manner, which should not lead to sanctions.
“No, I don’t think his comments will result in any sanction,” Hackett told Tottenham News.
“I am still unsure that it was Haaland who handled the ball—or if there was any contact with his arm at all. Referee Gillett, who officiated really well overall, was quick and confident in his decision-making.
“If there was any contact with the ball, I think it was the Tottenham player. I do not expect any punishment for Haaland, as he was simply expressing his opinion in a reasonable manner.”
Hackett’s assessment adds further weight to the growing debate around VAR’s role in the Premier League and the consistency of refereeing decisions. Many fans and pundits believe that such controversial moments highlight the need for greater transparency in how referees make key decisions, particularly when VAR is involved.
While Haaland avoided outright condemnation of the officials, his frustration is shared by many players and managers across the league who have repeatedly called for improvements in officiating standards. The incident will likely reignite discussions around whether VAR should be reformed or refined to minimize subjective calls that can significantly impact results.
Tottenham’s Winning Streak Ends Despite Encouraging Performance
While the focus of the match was largely on the officiating controversy, Tottenham’s performance deserves recognition, as Ange Postecoglou’s side put in a strong showing despite suffering their first Premier League defeat since January.
Heading into the match, Spurs had strung together three consecutive league victories, showcasing their ability to compete with the league’s top teams. However, their winning run was ultimately halted by one of the most clinical strikers in world football.
Despite the defeat, Tottenham did not go down without a fight. The North London club grew into the game in the second half, applying sustained pressure on Manchester City’s defense. Pedro Porro was particularly lively, sending in a series of dangerous crosses from the right flank that threatened City’s backline.
However, Tottenham’s inability to convert their chances proved costly, as City’s defense held firm to preserve their lead. In the end, Haaland’s first-half strike proved to be the difference, reinforcing his status as one of the most decisive players in world football.
Postecoglou Looks Ahead to Europa League Challenge
While the defeat will be disappointing for Ange Postecoglou and his players, the Australian manager will take positives from his team’s display, particularly in their attacking intent and defensive resilience against one of the strongest sides in the league.
With their Premier League winning streak halted, Spurs will now shift their focus to European competition as they prepare for a crucial Europa League clash against AZ Alkmaar next Thursday.
Postecoglou will be hoping his team can bounce back quickly from the defeat and use their recent momentum to push for European success. A strong showing in the Europa League could not only restore confidence within the squad but also serve as a stepping stone for further progress under Postecoglou’s leadership.
As for Haaland and Manchester City, their title challenge remains on track, but the controversy surrounding his disallowed goal will linger in the footballing debate for weeks to come. Whether the FA takes action or not, the incident has once again sparked widespread discussions on the state of officiating in the Premier League, ensuring that refereeing decisions will remain under scrutiny as the season progresses.
“He cancelled Halaand goal simply because…” – Two Ex- PL Official referees Reveals Erling Halaand will likely face severe punishment from FA after his comments triggered investigations
