Newcastle United endured a tough night at Anfield as they succumbed to a 2-0 defeat against Liverpool on Wednesday. Eddie Howe’s side struggled to impose themselves on the match, managing just 38% possession and failing to register a single shot on target. The loss leaves the Magpies in sixth place in the Premier League table, once again outside the Champions League qualification spots—though only two points behind fifth-placed Chelsea.
While few expected Newcastle to pull off a victory at Anfield, the manner of the defeat was particularly frustrating for fans. The Magpies were missing star striker Alexander Isak, who reportedly picked up an injury following the win against Nottingham Forest. This forced Callum Wilson into the starting lineup, but the striker failed to make a significant impact against Liverpool’s resolute defense.
Adding to Newcastle’s woes, goalkeeper Nick Pope was under scrutiny once again. After facing criticism from fans for his performance in the win against Forest, many had hoped he would redeem himself. However, the 32-year-old looked unconvincing throughout the match and was arguably at fault for Liverpool’s goals. While former Liverpool midfielder Steve McManaman defended Pope, some Newcastle supporters are eager to see Martin Dúbravka return to the starting lineup in the near future.
John Anderson Criticizes Bruno Guimarães’ Display
Newcastle’s performance against Liverpool raised concerns, and former Toon star John Anderson pinpointed Bruno Guimarães as a player who has been struggling in recent weeks. Anderson, who serves as a commentator for BBC Radio Newcastle, has witnessed Newcastle’s ups and downs this season, and he categorized Wednesday’s match as one of their lowest points.
Guimarães has been one of Newcastle’s standout players since joining the club, but his recent form has been a cause for concern. The Brazilian midfielder, known for his ability to evade pressure and dictate play, has looked far from his best in recent weeks. He has featured in every Premier League game this season, leading to speculation that fatigue may be affecting his performances.
Following the Liverpool match, Howe expressed his frustration with both Guimarães and Sandro Tonali, citing their mistakes as key moments that led to both goals. Anderson did not hold back in his assessment of Guimarães’ display, calling out the midfielder’s lackluster performance on BBC Radio Newcastle:
“I think he’s been awful lately. He looked like he couldn’t run, looked like he was chasing shadows. I think he’s been poor for a while.”
Guimarães was named Newcastle’s captain this season after discussions with Howe, where he expressed a desire to take on more responsibility within the club. However, with the armband comes the expectation of leadership, and Newcastle need their star midfielder to set an example for the rest of the squad.
Should Newcastle Rest Guimarães for the FA Cup?
Given his recent struggles, the upcoming FA Cup fifth-round tie against Brighton on Sunday could be an ideal opportunity to give Guimarães a much-needed rest. Newcastle have already rotated their squad heavily in the competition, and Howe may look to do the same once again, especially with bigger fixtures looming.
With the Carabao Cup final approaching, Howe will want his key players—Guimarães included—to be fresh and firing on all cylinders. Resting him against Brighton could allow him to recover both physically and mentally before Newcastle’s critical league fixtures.
Fortunately, Howe has options in midfield. Lewis Miley has impressed since breaking into the first team, particularly after Joelinton’s injury. Meanwhile, Sean Longstaff remains a reliable choice for the manager. In extreme circumstances, Howe could even deploy versatile players like Lewis Hall, Anthony Gordon, or Matt Targett in a midfield role if needed.
While Guimarães remains a crucial part of Newcastle’s long-term plans, it’s clear that he needs time to reset. Resting him in the FA Cup could be a strategic move that benefits both the player and the team as they push for a strong finish to the season.
Heart-broken John Anderson show his DISAPPOINTMENT at Newcastle United Star who looked like “he couldn’t run” vs Liverpool
