The Athletic: Everton now eyeing move to sign Aston Villa “superstar” for Moyes

Everton Plot Move for Aston Villa Captain John McGinn Amid Midfield Overhaul

 

Everton are reportedly setting their sights on Aston Villa midfielder John McGinn as part of a major squad rebuild during the current transfer window, according to a report from The Athletic.

 

The Toffees are preparing for what promises to be a busy and transformative summer at Goodison Park. Following several player departures—including the exit of long-serving midfielder Abdoulaye Doucouré at the end of his contract and the conclusion of Orel Mangala’s loan spell—Everton are keen to strengthen their options in the middle of the park.

 

So far, the Merseyside club have confirmed just one new senior addition: Carlos Alcaraz, whose loan from Southampton has been made permanent. While that deal signals a step in the right direction, manager Sean Dyche and the recruitment team are eager to further reinforce the squad with experienced Premier League talent.

 

One player firmly on Everton’s radar is Aston Villa’s club captain, John McGinn. The Scottish international, who has been a cornerstone of Villa’s midfield since joining from Hibernian in 2018, is admired by Everton for his tenacity, leadership, and top-flight experience. According to The Athletic, the Toffees have identified McGinn as a key target who could bring stability and grit to their midfield unit.

 

Villa, however, are understood to be reluctant to part ways with the 30-year-old, who played a pivotal role in the club’s successful 2024/25 campaign that included Champions League qualification. McGinn is not only viewed as a vital presence on the pitch but also an influential figure in the dressing room. Any potential deal would therefore be challenging, both from a negotiation and financial standpoint.

 

McGinn, once described as a “superstar” by former professional footballer Lee Mair, has racked up over 200 appearances for Villa and has worn the captain’s armband with pride. His blend of industriousness, passing range, and eye for goal has made him a fan favourite at Villa Park.

 

Everton’s interest in the Scotsman is partly fueled by the departure of veteran defender Ashley Young, who, despite his position, played an important leadership role within the squad. McGinn could help fill that void while also elevating the midfield’s overall quality.

 

That said, signing McGinn would not come without risks. At 30, he is entering the latter stages of his prime years, and his transfer fee is expected to be substantial—potentially stretching Everton’s budget given the club’s financial constraints. Furthermore, his limited resale value may make the investment harder to justify for a club looking to build for the long term.

 

With Aston Villa intent on retaining McGinn’s services ahead of their European campaign and Everton assessing several options to reshape their squad, this developing story will be one to watch closely in the coming weeks. Should the Toffees push ahead with their pursuit, they may need to act swiftly and decisively to test Villa’s resolve.