Newcastle United’s hopes of securing their first major silverware since 1969 have been dealt a significant blow, as they prepare to take on their Carabao Cup final opponents without three key players. The Magpies, who were full of optimism after their semi-final triumph over Arsenal, are now facing a major selection headache due to injuries and suspension.
Newcastle’s Wembley Dream Takes a Hit
Following their dramatic victory in the semi-finals, Newcastle fans were dreaming of finally bringing a long-awaited trophy back to Tyneside. Eddie Howe, determined to make amends for last year’s painful defeat to Manchester United in the 2023 final, has been working tirelessly to ensure his team learns from past mistakes. However, those plans have taken a hit in recent days, with injuries and suspensions leaving the squad depleted at a crucial time.
Newcastle will be without Lewis Hall and Sven Botman, both of whom have suffered injuries requiring surgery. While there remains some uncertainty over Botman’s potential return before the end of the campaign, Hall has been definitively ruled out for the rest of the season.
To compound their woes, Anthony Gordon will also be unavailable after receiving a red card for violent conduct during Newcastle’s defeat to Brighton. His suspension will see him miss the final, as well as the upcoming Premier League fixtures against West Ham and Brentford.
With Newcastle now short of options in key positions, Eddie Howe may be forced to turn to the club’s under-21 squad for reinforcements. Several young talents have impressed at the academy level this season, and some could be handed a golden opportunity to step up on one of the biggest stages in English football.
Three Young Players Who Could Step Up for Newcastle
Cathal Heffernan – The Defensive Cover Option
With Botman ruled out and defensive depth now a concern, Newcastle could call upon 19-year-old Cathal Heffernan as an emergency option at centre-back. The young Irish defender, who joined Newcastle from AC Milan in 2023, has made steady progress and has been a key figure for the under-21s this season, featuring in 18 matches across all competitions.
While Dan Burn and Fabian Schär are expected to start at Wembley, Heffernan could serve as a backup in case of any last-minute issues. Though naturally a right-footed player, he has demonstrated the ability to play as a left-sided centre-back, making him a viable replacement for either Burn or Schär if needed.
Heffernan has already had a taste of first-team involvement, having been part of Newcastle’s pre-season squad last summer. He also featured in their 4-1 victory over Urawa Red Diamonds during their Japan tour, giving Howe some confidence in his ability to handle the step up.
Dylan Charlton – A Promising Left-Back Alternative
Newcastle’s issues at left-back could present a massive opportunity for 18-year-old Dylan Charlton, who has impressed as a regular starter for the under-21s this season. Since head coach Diarmuid O’Carroll took charge of the youth setup in 2024, Charlton has cemented himself as the team’s primary left-back and has shown steady development.
The most likely defensive reshuffle for the cup final would see Tino Livramento shift to left-back, with Matt Targett on the bench. However, if Howe wants extra cover, Charlton could earn a spot among the substitutes.
Much like Heffernan, Charlton was involved in the senior squad during pre-season and was part of the Newcastle team that faced the A-League All-Stars last May. While that match ended in a heavy 8-0 defeat, it provided the youngster with valuable experience at a higher level. Given the club’s current lack of depth in this position, Charlton could at the very least be called up for first-team training in preparation for the final.
Garang Kuol – A Surprise Attacking Option?
One of the most exciting young prospects in Newcastle’s setup is Garang Kuol, and with Anthony Gordon suspended, the door could be open for the Australian forward to earn a place on the bench.
Kuol’s early days at Newcastle were difficult, with two underwhelming loan spells stalling his progress. However, he has since found his rhythm by staying with the under-21 squad, where he has been a key player in 2025. He has registered two goals and two assists in the Premier League 2 this season and played an important role in Newcastle’s National League Cup campaign.
His recent performance in a 4-1 victory over Stoke drew praise from fans, some of whom have called for him to be given an opportunity in the first team. Kuol also has experience on big stages, having been part of Australia’s 2022 World Cup squad, where he played against Lionel Messi’s Argentina.
While Howe is more likely to turn to Harvey Barnes or Joelinton to fill the gap left by Gordon, Kuol’s recent form could see him earn a place on the bench for the final. His pace, flair, and ability to operate in attacking areas might provide Newcastle with an extra option late in the game.
Final Thoughts: A Testing Time for Howe
With three key players missing, Eddie Howe faces a difficult task in selecting his squad for the Carabao Cup final. The injuries to Botman and Hall, combined with Gordon’s suspension, mean that Newcastle will have to dig deep to compete at Wembley.
While experienced first-team players will be expected to step up, young talents like Heffernan, Charlton, and Kuol could find themselves in contention for a place in the squad. Whether any of them are called upon remains to be seen, but Newcastle’s academy prospects may be about to experience the biggest moment of their careers so far.
Regardless of the challenges ahead, Newcastle fans will remain hopeful that their side can defy the odds and bring home the club’s first major trophy in over half a century.
Directly from Eddie Howe- Toons unleash ‘Unbelievable’ wonderkid and two other academy gems who will play for Newcastle Carabao Cup final vs Liverpool
