Harry Kane has been urged to snub a return to Tottenham Hotspur and instead sign for Arsenal if he hopes to break Alan Shearer’s all-time Premier League goalscoring record. The stunning claim comes from former Gunners midfielder Paul Merson, who believes the England captain would have a better chance of cementing his legacy in North London—but not with the club where he made his name.
The 30-year-old striker made a blockbuster move to Bayern Munich in the summer of 2023, ending his long association with Spurs in search of silverware. His departure was one of the biggest transfer stories of the window, with Bayern paying over £100 million to secure his signature. However, despite his individual brilliance in Germany, Kane endured a trophyless first season with the Bundesliga giants—something that has continued to elude him throughout his career.
Still, his form in front of goal has been nothing short of phenomenal. Since joining Bayern, Kane has racked up a staggering 72 goals in just 73 appearances across all competitions. His prolificacy has only reinforced the notion that he remains one of the best strikers in the world, capable of thriving at the highest level.
Could Kane Return to the Premier League?
While Kane is reportedly happy at Bayern Munich, speculation about his long-term future has refused to die down. Reports have emerged suggesting that a release clause was inserted into his Bayern contract, potentially allowing him to make a return to England sooner than many expected.
Several Premier League clubs are said to be aware of this clause, which could pave the way for a dramatic comeback. Naturally, the club most frequently linked with a potential move is Tottenham, where Kane spent nearly two decades and became the club’s all-time leading goalscorer. However, Paul Merson has thrown a curveball into the discussion, urging Kane to break ties with his former club and instead move across North London to Arsenal.
Speaking on Sky Sports, the Arsenal legend argued that if Kane wants to surpass Alan Shearer’s record of 260 Premier League goals, he should avoid returning to Spurs and instead join a club with a stronger chance of winning titles—naming Arsenal as the perfect destination.
“I keep on saying Alexander Isak because I think he’s a top striker, but there’s not a lot of world-class forwards available right now,” Merson said. “If I were Arsenal, I’d go all out for Harry Kane. I’d pay the £60-odd million to bring him in. I know it’s not my money, but if they’re looking for a proven goalscorer, Kane is the best option on the market.”
Merson went on to highlight Sol Campbell’s controversial move from Tottenham to Arsenal in 2001, arguing that footballers ultimately prioritize success over loyalty.
“People said Sol Campbell wouldn’t go to Arsenal, but he did. If Kane is serious about breaking Shearer’s record, there’s no point in going back to Tottenham just for that,” he continued. “Arsenal would give him a much better platform to do it. They create chances, they’re competing for titles, and he’d be surrounded by world-class players. Why wouldn’t he consider it?”
Kane’s Premier League Ambitions Remain
Although Kane has never explicitly stated his desire to return to the Premier League, he has acknowledged that Shearer’s record is something he keeps in mind.
Speaking during his Bayern Munich unveiling, Kane admitted that the record is an ambition for him, but he remains fully focused on his time in Germany for now.
“People will talk about the record and Shearer, but I’ve got plenty of football left in my career,” Kane said at the time. “For now, it’s about trying to achieve things here at Bayern and pushing myself and the team to new levels. That’s all my focus is on right now.”
However, he was notably tight-lipped when recently asked about the rumored release clause in his Bayern contract.
“What I can say is that I’m very happy at FC Bayern. No comment on the clause,” Kane responded, leaving the door open for further speculation.
What Are the Chances of Kane Moving to Arsenal?
A move to Arsenal would undoubtedly be one of the most shocking transfers in Premier League history, considering Kane’s deep ties to Tottenham. The striker spent nearly 20 years at Spurs, progressing through the academy and becoming their all-time leading goalscorer with 280 goals in 435 appearances.
While Tottenham fans would undoubtedly be furious at the mere suggestion of Kane joining their biggest rivals, from a footballing perspective, it isn’t entirely out of the question. Arsenal are one of the strongest teams in England right now, competing for Premier League titles and featuring a young, dynamic squad under Mikel Arteta. Adding a proven world-class striker like Kane could be the final piece of the puzzle to elevate them to genuine Champions League contenders.
That said, there are major obstacles to such a move. Tottenham chairman Daniel Levy would likely do everything in his power to prevent Kane from signing for Arsenal, just as he refused to sell him to Manchester City in 2021. Furthermore, Kane himself may hesitate to tarnish his legacy at Tottenham by joining their biggest rivals.
What’s Next for Kane?
For now, Kane remains fully committed to Bayern Munich as they continue their Champions League campaign. The German giants are set to face Celtic in the first leg of their knockout playoff tie, with Kane expected to play a pivotal role in their push for European success.
While his short-term future is clear, his long-term plans remain a topic of intense debate. If he eventually chooses to return to England, it will inevitably spark a bidding war—with Arsenal potentially waiting in the shadows for the opportunity to pull off one of the most sensational transfers in modern football history.
HARRY KANE TO ARSENAL GETS HUGE INCENTIVE TO AGREE TO SHOCK ARSENAL MOVE AMID BAYERN’S CALL TO SELL HIM
